******************** THIS BLOG HAS MOVED TO WWW.LEGALINSURRECTION.COM ********************

This blog is moving to www.legalinsurrection.com. If you have not been automatically redirected please click on the link.

NEW COMMENTS will NOT be put through and will NOT be transferred to the new website.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Nationalize Martin Luther King Jr.

We are in the process of nationalizing and/or federalizing vast stretches of our economy, including the auto industry, banks, and health care. Individual property rights have taken a back seat to political priorities.

I am against this trampling of individual property rights, which are the foundation of our democracy. But if it is going to happen because of the large Democrat majorities in Congress and Obama's personal popularity, then there is one aspect of the economy Democrats should nationalize before anything else: The history of Martin Luther King, Jr.

We created a national MLK holiday in 1986, thereby elevating MLK to a position in the nation's history almost unparalleled in over 200 years. Virtually every school in the country devotes more time to discussing MLK's legacy than the history of any president or war. More so than the election of Barack Obama, the MLK holiday was a turning point in race relations and the recognition of the lingering effects of slavery and segregation.

Yet much of the history of MLK remains off limits to the public, and is controlled through copyright and other intellectual property rights by MLK's family members. Such historic speeches such as the "I Have a Dream" are owned by MLK's family through a foundation:
All of King's speeches and papers are owned by his family, which has gone to court several times since the 1990s to protect its copyright; King obtained rights to his most famous speech a month after he gave it. Now, those who want to hear or use the speech in its entirety must buy a copy sanctioned by the King family, which receives the proceeds.
Few people realize that reprinting the "I Have a Dream" speech without permission of MLK's family, and in many cases the payment of royalties, will result at a minimum in a nasty lawyer letter, and even a lawsuit. These efforts to maintain copyright control over MLK's speeches are international in scope.

The latest example is an attempt by two MLK family members to stop a film about MLK's life because some copyrighted material was used without permission or payment of royalties:
DreamWorks plans the first big-screen portrayal of the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.'s life, the studio announced Tuesday, but two of King's children immediately threatened legal action because the film deal was brokered without their blessing.
For MLK's family members, the economic structure they have created could not be better. They have nationalized their father's persona, but profit by controlling the written and spoken words which memorialize his history. While the foundation may be not-for-profit, the salaries and other perks the family garners are hardly not-for-nothing.

The time has come to end this madness. If Democrats are going to nationalize much of the economy over the protests of Republicans and independents, then Democrats should first nationalize Martin Luther King, Jr.'s history, including the "I Have a Dream" speech.

UPDATE: Jonathan Turley has a post in which he argues that the King family should have been compelled to waive copyright protection in exchange for the King Memorial on the National Mall:

The King children are at it again: demanding consultation (and presumably payment) for any work on their father. Recently, I wrote a column denouncing the King family’s history of bilking authors, institutions, and even the King Memorial committee for money....

When you give a speech on the congressional mall, it should belong to the nation. More importantly, Congress should have premised the creation of the King memorial on the family releasing this speech to the public domain (as President release their documents in exchange for presidential libraries.

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Greatest Sentence Ever (feat. H. Reid)
Word Games In Defense Of Pelosi
Pelosi Surrounds Herself With Herself

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Word Games In Defense Of Pelosi

The controversy over Nancy Pelosi's accusation that the CIA repeatedly misled her and Congress as to detainee interrogation has taken a new turn: Word games.

What Pelosi knew, when she knew it, and what she did in reaction, rightly has become a center of attention because it is a test of the Democratic party's credibility. If Bush administration officials are to be prosecuted, which appears unlikely but still hoped-for by some, then Democratic leaders have to explain why they went along with the interrogation program. I don't know if Pelosi is telling the truth that she was misled, but by making such an accusation she should either give the evidence under oath, or withdraw the charge.

But those who are defending Pelosi don't seek to hold her to that test. Instead, what we are getting is the equivalent of Bill Clinton's argument over what the meaning of "is" is.

In a post in TPM Muckraker, widely linked in the left-wing blogosphere, an argument is made that the statement of CIA Director Leon Panetta that Pelosi was given accurate information at a September 2002 briefing and later briefings, is suspect because of a term used in a recently-compiled document listing dates of briefings.

According to this argument, the briefing list uses the term "EIT" (enhanced interrogation techniques), but there is no public record of such term being used prior to 2004. Therefore, the argument goes, since the term EIT was not used in 2003-2003, but is used in the briefing list, there is doubt that Nancy Pelosi was briefed on EITs in 2002-2003.

This argument is so weak, it is almost hard to know where to begin. First, the briefing list, being recently compiled, is a summary of underlying documentation. Panetta's defense of the CIA was based on the underlying documentation of what was covered in the briefings. If the briefing list used a descriptive term for interrogation techniques which term was not in use in 2002, that does not negate that the techniques were discussed.

Second, TPM is basing it defense of Pelosi on public databases. I have no idea if the term EIT was used within the intelligence or defense communities prior to 2004, and neither does TPM. Since the information was classified until recently, it would not be surprising if the term was used internally earlier than used in public. My guess is as good as TPM's, except at least I admit to guessing.

Third, Pelosi herself admits to having the techniques in question described to her in September 2002. The area of dispute is whether, as she claims, she was told that waterboarding specifically had not been used. We also know that at least one Pelosi staff member was briefed in early 2003 that waterboarding had been used, and reported that information to Pelosi. So regardless of whether the term EIT was used, Pelosi's own account of events concurs with that of the CIA briefing list except on the issue of how waterboarding was described to Pelosi in September 2002.

The entire argument in defense of Pelosi based on the use of the term EIT is just one big word game which, if carried forward, ends up contradicting Pelosi's own account. Not much of a defense.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Sy Hersh DID Claim Cheney Ran "An Executive Assassination Ring"

A Pakistani newspaper, The Nation, published a story claiming that former Vice President Dick Cheney ran an assassination squad which killed, among others, Benazir Bhutto of Pakistan:

Former prime minister of Pakistan Benazir Bhutto was assassinated on the orders of the special death squad formed by former US vice-president Dick Cheney, which had already killed the Lebanese Prime Minister Rafique Al Hariri and the army chief of that country. The squad was headed by General Stanley McChrystal, the newly-appointed commander of US army in Afghanistan. It was disclosed by reputed US journalist Seymour Hersh while talking to an Arab TV in an interview.
Hersh is denying the story (italics in quote mine):
US journalist Seymour Hersh on Monday contradicted news reports being published in South Asia that quote him as saying a “special death squad” made by former US vice president Dick Cheney had killed Benazir Bhutto. The award-winning journalist described as “complete madness” the reports that the squad headed by General Stanley McChrystal – the new commander of US army in Afghanistan – had also killed former Lebanese prime minister Rafique Al Hariri and a Lebanese army chief. “Vice president Cheney does not have a death squad. I have no idea who killed Mr Hariri or Mrs Bhutto,” Hersh said. “I have never said that I did have such information. I most certainly did not say anything remotely to that effect during an interview with an Arab media outlet.” He said Gen McChrystal had run a special forces unit that engaged in “high value target activity”, but “while I have been critical of some of that unit’s activities in the pages of the New Yorker and in interviews, I have never suggested that he was involved in political assassinations or death squads on behalf of Mr Cheney, as the published stories state.”
But Hersh's denial is untrue in part. While there is no record that I'm aware of in which Hersh claimed that Cheney had Bhutto assassinated, there is a recorded statement by Hersh, given during a speech at the University of Minnesota, in which Hersh claimed that the Bush administration had "an executive assassination ring" that reported directly to Cheney:

Right now, today, there was a story in the New York Times that if you read it carefully mentioned something known as the Joint Special Operations Command -- JSOC it’s called. It is a special wing of our special operations community that is set up independently. They do not report to anybody, except in the Bush-Cheney days, they reported directly to the Cheney office. They did not report to the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff or to Mr. [Robert] Gates, the secretary of defense. They reported directly to him. ...

Congress has no oversight of it. It’s an executive assassination ring essentially, and it’s been going on and on and on. Just today in the Times there was a story that its leaders, a three star admiral named [William H.] McRaven, ordered a stop to it because there were so many collateral deaths.

Listen to the video below starting at 13:30.

So while Hersh is denying being the source for the story of Cheney assassinating Bhutto, it is not surprising that Hersh was cited as the source given Hersh's prior statements.


UPDATE: Jules Crittendon has a good round-up of Hersh's history on the topic, and Moe Lane has an MSNBC video of Keith Olbermann singing Hersh's praises on the supposed Cheney-run assassination squad. Now that Hersh has recanted his claim that Cheney had a "death squad," will Olbermann recant?

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Monday, May 18, 2009

Nancy Pelosi Is The Central Issue

My article, Nancy Pelosi Is The Central Issue, appears today at American Thinker:

Nancy Pelosi recently accused the CIA of misleading Congress as to interrogation techniques employed against three al-Qaeda leaders. The CIA pushed back, claiming that Pelosi was given truthful details at briefings at least as early as September 2002. Democratic leaders and left-wing blogs have portrayed the controversy as a distraction. To the contrary, what Pelosi knew, when she knew it, and how she reacted are essential to putting events in historical context, rather than engaging in disingenuous moralizing or political theater.

The battle over interrogations takes place on legal, moral and political fronts. On the legal front, the issue is definitional. What constitutes unlawful "torture" as opposed to lawful interrogation? The criminal statute defining torture, 18 U.S.C. sec. 2340, is vague and leaves much to interpretation. Torture is defined as "an act committed by a person acting under the color of law specifically intended to inflict severe physical or mental pain or suffering...."

The key wording in the statute is "specifically intended" and "severe." A generalized intent to cause harm, but not necessarily severe pain or suffering, is not a crime. Similarly, a specific intent to cause some, but not severe, pain or suffering also is not a violation. There are no guidelines as to what constitutes severe pain or suffering.

The four previously-classified legal memoranda released by President Obama in April were an attempt by Justice Department lawyers to interpret this vague statute in the context of specific interrogation techniques the CIA believed were necessary to prevent future attacks. The memoranda go through a detailed analysis, which some inaccurately describe as banal, in order to apply the law to the specific set of facts.

Despite calls for prosecution of the authors of the memoranda, and those who relied on them, it appears that there will be no prosecutions. There likely were no crimes committed under the specific wording of the law, and Obama does not want his agenda sidetracked by the desire of some to get revenge on the Bush administration.

Lacking a legal remedy, many people have resorted to a different front, moral indignation. This indignation is genuine in some and feigned in others. In this view, whether waterboarding and other harsh methods constituted torture under the law is irrelevant; keeping someone awake for days, in uncomfortable positions for long periods, or using waterboarding, never is justified even to save lives.

People who refuse to use harsh interrogation methods (whether "torture" or not) as an honest matter of conscience, deserve respect, much like conscientious objectors. This is why when we had a draft we distinguished someone who simply didn't want to serve in the military from someone who had such a profound believe that killing was wrong regardless of circumstance that he could not in good conscience serve in the military.

The moral high ground, however, is not what is at play in the current interrogation debate. No prominent politician, Democratic or Republican, is willing to sacrifice a city for the sake of moral purity. The same people who decry the waterboarding of the mastermind of 9/11 are silent when Obama orders missile attacks on Pakistan which inevitably cause civilian casualties. To continue the analogy, in this debate there are many draft evaders and few conscientious objectors.

The real front in this battle is not the law or morality, but politics. The response of many leading Democrats in Congress, including Nancy Pelosi, is to call for a "truth commission" to expose the use of harsh interrogation methods. A truth commission cannot prosecute, but it can humiliate. When Democrats talk about bringing out the truth, what they really mean is that they want a political circus aimed at the Bush administration alone. To accomplish this mission, the interrogations must be viewed in isolation from the historical events in which they took place, with morality used in hearings as a sword not a principle. To these Democrats, the only truth which matters is what was done to whom and when.

In reality, what was done to whom cannot be viewed outside the context of when it took place. The use of nuclear weapons against Japan is a good example. One could take the position that the use of nuclear weapons, with the inevitable civilian casualties, never is justified. But in the context, the alternatives were the survival of an Imperial Japan with its legacy of brutal pillage throughout Asia or a bloody invasion of the Japanese mainland which would have killed more people (both American and Japanese). In this context, the moral wrong of a nuclear weapon was the lesser of two evils, and was the only politically acceptable solution at the time.

So too, the use of waterboarding and other interrogation methods cannot be viewed in isolation from the historical events in which they were used. In 2002-2003, when most of the controversial interrogations took place, the nation justifiably was fearful of imminent attack from al-Qaeda. The three individuals subjected to waterboarding were believed to have information vital to stopping attacks which were in the planning or operational stages. Waterboarding these three was viewed at the time as the lesser of two evils, the alternative being more dead Americans.

And it is this historical context which the Democrats wish to evade, and which makes what Nancy Pelosi knew and when she knew it absolutely critical.

Far from being a distraction, the information provided to Pelosi, and her acquiescence in the interrogation methods, puts the whole debate in proper historical context. If Pelosi, who states that she is against "torture" under any circumstance, was willing to go along with the interrogation methods, then the planned political circus falls apart. Nancy Pelosi was the classic example of a person who opposed certain interrogation methods in principle, but under certain circumstances and certain places in time was willing to go along or look the other way because the alternative was worse.

Historical context and national self-defense are essential to the truth of how we should view the interrogation of al-Qaeda leaders. But these are the very topics which would be avoided or obscured unless what Nancy Pelosi knew, when she knew it, and how she reacted are the central focuses of any inquiry.
--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Sunday, May 17, 2009

CBS News On Souter Replacement

My comments appear at 0.30 of the video, here.

(I have removed the embedded CBS video since it apparently had an auto-run feature which understandably annoyed some viewers; if I can figure out how to get rid of the auto-run, I'll repost it)


--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Saturday, May 16, 2009

Pelosi May 2002 Statement Casts Further Doubt On Her Claims

Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi has denied being briefed in September 2002 about the waterboarding of Abu Zubaydah. Pelosi claims she was told that the technique had not been used (when in fact it had been used a month earlier). Pelosi uses this September 2002 briefing, and the alleged concealment of waterboarding, to support her claim that the CIA misled Congress.

Pelosi says she first learned of the waterboarding in February 2003, when her aide was briefed on the issue, and relayed the information to her. CIA Director Leon Panetta states that CIA records show that Pelosi was in fact briefed on the techniques used on Zubaydah at the September 2002 briefing.

We do not know at this time what other records exist showing what was said at the September 2002 briefing, but this quotation from Pelosi in May 2002 lends credibility to the CIA's account. Pelosi clearly was being kept apprised of the specific details Zubaybah's interrogation and the difficulty of getting Zubaydah to give up all he knew.

In May 2002, the government announced a terror alert based in part on information Zubaydah had revealed about attacks on the Brooklyn Bridge and other landmarks, although Zubaydah was being evasive as to whether there was an active plan. Pelosi was quoted as being aware of the details of the interrogation (italics in quotation mine):
CNN.com, May 22, 2002: Last Monday night, the New York Joint Terrorism Task Force--a round-the-clock operation at the New York field office of the FBI--got a call from FBI headquarters. Abu Zubaydah, the highest al-Qaeda official to be captured by the U.S., had told interrogators that he had heard other Osama bin Laden loyalists discussing attacks on the Brooklyn Bridge, the Statue of Liberty and other U.S. landmarks. But, a federal law-enforcement official told TIME, Abu Zubaydah had said the conversations took place a while back and claimed he knew of no particular plan. Since his capture in March, Abu Zubaydah has shared some valuable information, says a senior U.S. intelligence source. "He's not b.s.ing us on everything." Then again, says Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi, senior Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, "he is also very skilled at avoiding interrogation. He is an agent of disinformation."
So as of May 2002, Pelosi knew the details of the interrogation of Zubaydah, and the problems the CIA was encountering due to Zubaydah's evasiveness. It does not take any leap of imagination to believe that Pelosi, then the senior Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, would have been kept informed of the progress of the interrogation, including the use of waterboarding months later.

It would take an incredible leap of imagination to believe that the CIA would tell Pelosi about all the problems with the interrogation of Zubaydah, but not tell her what was being done to solve those problems. Particularly when the waterboarding revealed that the plot against the Brooklyn Bridge, about which Pelosi publicly spoke, was revealed to be real based on information Zubaydah provided after being waterboarded.

A leap of imagination is exactly what Pelosi is asking us to do with her ever-changing explanations.

---------------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
►Pelosi Accuses CIA Of Lying
►Dems Lack Waterboarding Exit Strategy
►Pelosi Surrounds Herself With Herself

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Friday, May 15, 2009

Two Heartbeats Away

Two heartbeats away from President Barack Obama, in the line of succession, sits the Speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi.

Two heartbeats away from the Presidency sits someone who has alleged that the Central Intelligence Agency repeatedly misled Congress as to the interrogation of terrorist detainees, thereby accusing the CIA of a massive and possibly criminal scheme.

Two heartbeats away from the Presidency sits someone whose accusations have been denied by the Director of the CIA appointed by Obama.

Two heartbeats away from the Presidency sits someone who has control over the legislative appropriations process which can have a critical impact on the safety and security of the nation, including the intelligence agency budgets.

The public needs to know whether the person two heartbeats away from the Presidency is telling the truth about what she knew and when she knew it.

The person two heartbeats away from the Presidency immediately should provide law enforcement officials with the evidence she has, including testimony under oath, to back up her allegations of criminal conduct by the CIA, so that a criminal investigation can proceed if warranted.

If the person two heartbeats away from the Presidency is not willing to put her own criminal liability on the line in making these accusations against the CIA, she should resign.

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
►Pelosi Accuses CIA Of Lying
►Dems Lack Waterboarding Exit Strategy
►Pelosi Surrounds Herself With Herself

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Obama's Health Care Fraud

Obama knows that there is no way to pay for universal health care insurance coverage. He also knows that there is no way to borrow enough money for such coverage. The well is running dry on the national credit card.

The solution: Cut health care costs to pay for expanded coverage. Obama trumpeted a plan with industry executives to trim $1.5 trillion in costs. But this wasn't a cut in costs, merely a cut in the rate of increase in costs. Even so, the plan was heralded:
President Barack Obama on Monday welcomed the health care industry's promise to cut $2 trillion in costs over 10 years and vowed to keep working tirelessly to find a solution to the problem of uninsured Americans.

Hospitals, insurance companies, drug makers and doctors told Obama in a letter that they will voluntarily slow their rate increases in coming years in a move that government economists say would create breathing room to help provide health insurance to an estimated 50 million Americans who now go without it.

One big problem. The Obama administration twisted private industry's willingness to look into a problem as a promise to do what the administration wanted:

Hospitals and insurance companies said Thursday that President Obama had substantially overstated their promise earlier this week to reduce the growth of health spending....

“These groups are voluntarily coming together to make an unprecedented commitment,” Mr. Obama said. “Over the next 10 years, from 2010 to 2019, they are pledging to cut the rate of growth of national health care spending by 1.5 percentage points each year — an amount that’s equal to over $2 trillion.”

Health care leaders who attended the meeting have a different interpretation. They say they agreed to slow health spending in a more gradual way and did not pledge specific year-by-year cuts.

This episode is reminiscent of Obama's overstating the supposed promise by Caterpillar to rehire workers if the stimulus package passed. Caterpillar disputed that any such promise was made, and ended up laying off more workers, not rehiring.

Why should the public put any faith in the administration's health care cost projections, when such projections are "just words" and based on nothing more than political spin?

--------------------------------------------
Related Post: $1 Trillion "Downpayment" For Health Insurance Announced

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Monkey Run Law Firm

As my loyal readers know, I long have been a fan of the Google Ads algorithm. The ad on this blog for Big Beautiful Women continues to generate an amazing number of hits, usually from a google search by someone seeking a big beautiful woman. My favorites, though, were the racy McCain gay dating ads.

I have wondered what the world would come to if the Google Ads algorithm ran the world. Now I know:


-------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Welcome to Economic Bizarro Land

Critics, including me, of Obama's economic plans have made the point that the unprecedented huge deficits necessary to pay for expanded health insurance coverage, college education guarantees, the present and future "stimulus" plans, infrastructure projects, budget expansion, financing and operational takeovers of the auto industry and banking sectors, and other aspects of bigger government, are not sustainable.

(chart source here)

Such borrowing puts present and future generations at risk because sooner or later (probably sooner) we will be unable to borrow from the Chinese and other foreigners, and the result will be runaway inflation and higher interest rates.

Yet Obama plows ahead. It now is clear that Obama understands the danger, but races down the spending road nonetheless:

President Barack Obama, calling current deficit spending “unsustainable,” warned of skyrocketing interest rates for consumers if the U.S. continues to finance government by borrowing from other countries.

“We can’t keep on just borrowing from China,” Obama said at a town-hall meeting in Rio Rancho, New Mexico, outside Albuquerque.

“We have to pay interest on that debt, and that means we are mortgaging our children’s future with more and more debt.”

Holders of U.S. debt will eventually “get tired” of buying it, causing interest rates on everything from auto loans to home mortgages to increase, Obama said. “It will have dampening effect on our economy.”

The president pledged to work with Congress to shore up entitlement programs such as Social Security and Medicare and said he was confident that the House and Senate would pass health-care overhaul bills by August.

“Most of what is driving us into debt is health care, so we have to drive down costs,” he said.

The notion that we can drive down health care costs enough to offset multi-trillions of dollars of spending on a variety of items (not just expanded health care coverage) is delusional. When do health care costs ever decrease when combined with expanded services?

Welcome to economic bizarro land.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Pelosi Accuses CIA Of Lying

Nancy Pelosi is holding a press conference in which she has acknowledged being briefed by the CIA about waterboarding in 2002, but accuses the CIA of lying to Congress about the use of the technique and whether the techniques were legal. Pelosi also acknowledged, when pressed by questions, that she was told in 2003 by an assistant, that the CIA was using waterboarding. This puts Pelosi and Democrats in Congress who support her on a collision course with the intelligence community.

Pelosi claimed that she took action to stop the policies, by working to take control of Congress and passing legislation several years later. Pelosi also used a logical and political slight of hand by asserting that at the same time the Bush administration was misleading Congress about weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

Pelosi has upped the ante, and it seems inevitable that there will be a "truth commission" to find out what the person two heartbeats from the presidency knew, and when she knew it.

Updates to follow once the transcript is available. The press conference is ongoing, and the questioning is good and hard hitting, pointing out Pelosi's change in stories over time.

UPDATE: Here is the account of the press conference from Glenn Thrush at Politico.com:

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says Bush administration intelligence officials told her explicitly they weren't using waterboarding on terror detainees during a Sept. 2002 briefing on interrogation tactics -- months after they had begun waterboarding Abu Zabaydah.

Pelosi also called on CIA director Leon Panetta to release full details on her briefing -- and shook her head in the affirmative when asked if the administration had actually "lied" to her.

"The only mention of waterboarding in the briefing was that it was not being employed," she told reporters, reading from a prepared statement -- twice for emphasis.

The intelligence briefers gave Pelosi, she said, "inaccurate and incomplete information."

UPDATE No. 2: The transcript is available here. Here are excerpts, with my commentary in brackets throughout:

Like all members of Congress who are briefed on classified information, I have assigned oaths pledges not to disclose any of that information. [So I can make accusations, but you can't test me on them because I can't talk about the details] This is an oath I have taken very seriously, and I've always abided by it. The CIA briefed me [depends on the meaning of "briefed"] only once on enhanced interrogation techniques in September 2002 in my capacity as ranking member of the Intelligence Committee. I was informed then that the Department of Justice opinions had concluded that the use of enhanced interrogation techniques were legal. [But I am so against torture that I didn't think to ask if there were other opinions, or to ask to see the legal opinion so I could judge for myself.]

The only mention of waterboarding at that briefing was that it was not being employed. [Depends on the definition of "being employed"; were you told that they previously were used but not currently, or never had been used ever] Those conducting the briefing promised to inform the appropriate members of Congress if that technique were to be used in the future. [And they did, and I was told about it] Congress and the American people now know that, that contrary to the opinions within the -- contrary opinions within the executive branch concluded that these interrogation techniques were not legal. However, those opinions were not shared with Congress.

We also now know that techniques including waterboarding had already been employed and that those briefing me in September 2002 gave me inaccurate and incomplete information. At the same time, the Bush administration -- exactly the same time .... [let's change to subject and talk about Iraq]-- September of 2002, the fall of 2002, at the same time, the Bush administration was misleading the American people about the threat of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

Five months later [just five months, not five years], in February 2003, a member of my staff informed me [but I wasn't "briefed"] that the Republican chairman and the Democratic ranking member of the Intelligence Committee had been briefed about the use of certain techniques which had been the subject of earlier legal opinions.

Following that briefing, a letter raising concerns was sent to CIA general counsel, Scott Muller by the new Democratic ranking member of committee, the appropriate person to register a protest. But no letter could change the policy. [So why should I bother objecting also] It was clear we had to change the leadership in Congress and in the White House. [So I would not speak out about alleged torture for several years while we waited for Barack Obama to get elected to the Senate, to be annointed the great hope of the Democratic Party, and to run for President, all of which was the reason I decided in 2002-2003 to stay silent] .....

PELOSI: I have long supported creation of an independent truth commission to determine how intelligence was misused and how controversial and possibly illegal activities like torture were authorized within the executive branch. [But not whether I have been telling the truth, or what I knew and when I knew it] ....

QUESTION: Regardless of the individual who told you that these techniques were being used and regardless the venue in which you learned of this fact, does not the foreknowledge of the use of these techniques make you complicit in their use?

PELOSI: No, this is a policy that has been -- that was conceived and implemented by the Bush administration. They notified Congress that they had legal opinions saying that this was -- was legal, but they would let us know if they were planning to use them, is what they briefed us on. I think you can see by what Mr. Panetta has sent out that it's really hard to confirm what did happen, and the committees of jurisdiction may have to look into that, but it does not make me complicit, no.

QUESTION: But Mr. Sheehy...

PELOSI: Yes?

QUESTION: You say that Mr. Sheehy did tell you, your staff did tell you.

PELOSI: He informed me that the briefing had taken place. We were not in a place where he could -- that was all that he was required to do. .... I was not briefed on what was in that briefing; I was just informed that the briefing had taken place. [Oh, ok, now I get it. You were "told" but not "briefed"] ....

QUESTION: ... Sheehy did not tell you that the -- he was informed that they were actually using the techniques?

PELOSI: No, he did say that. He said that the -- the committee chair and ranking member and appropriate staff had been briefed that these techniques were now being used. [So you knew that they were being used and still said nothing] They -- that's all I was informed, that they were being used and that a letter was sent....

QUESTION: Madam Speaker, just to be clear, you're accusing the CIA of lying to you in September of 2002?

PELOSI: Yes, misleading the Congress of the United States, misleading the Congress of the United States. I am.

QUESTION: And also -- and doing it again now, as they've released this list of briefings that says you were briefed on the interrogation tactics that were used.

PELOSI: [At this point, I will keep talking in circles in the hope people get bored and stop trying to pin me down on what I knew and when I knew it] I'm saying -- I'm quoting what the head of the CIA has said. This is -- we don't know if this information is accurate that he's talking about. What they briefed us on -- and perhaps they should release the briefings. I would be very happy if they would release the briefings. And then you will see what they briefed in one time -- in one time and another, House and the Senate and the rest, and perhaps with the intense interest that this has generated because of the distraction that the Republicans want to cause with this, then you can make a judgment yourself about what you think these briefings were.

But I'm telling you that they talked about interrogations that they had done and said, "We want to use enhanced techniques, and we have legal opinions that say that they are OK. We are not using waterboarding." That's the only mention, that they were not using it. And we now know that earlier they were. So, yes, I am saying that they are misleading -- that the CIA was misleading the Congress. And at the same time, the administration was misleading the Congress on the weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, to which I said, "This intelligence does not support the imminent threat," to which the press asked the same question you just did now. "Are you accusing them of lying?" I said, I'm just stating a fact. The intelligence...

QUESTION: Do you wish now that you had done more? Do you wish...

PELOSI: No. [So everything I am complaining about would not have changed what I would have done, get it?]

QUESTION: ... it had been your own letter?

PELOSI: No, no, no, no, no, no. I mean, the point is, is that we had the conversation. They told us they had legal opinions. As I say in my statement, we now know what they didn't inform us then, that there were other opinions within the executive branch that concluded that these interrogation techniques were not legal. So no letter or anything else is going to stop them from doing what they're going to do. My job was to change the majority in Congress and to change -- to fight to have a new president, because what was happening was not consistent with our values, certainly not true, and -- and something that had to be changed....

QUESTION: OK. The question is: At the end of April, you had a press conference with us and you said very clearly we were not told that waterboarding or any of these other enhanced interrogation methods were used.

PELOSI: That's right. We, in that -- in that meeting, in the briefing that I received, we were not told that -- in fact, we were told that waterboarding was not being used because that's sort of one that stood out.

QUESTION: So in that press conference, we were all fairly trying to get at the broader question of whether -- whether you knew about waterboarding at all. And the idea that we got from you was that you were never told that waterboarding was being used. But now we know that, later, in February, you were told. It wasn't in that briefing, but you were told. So...

PELOSI: No. [or is it Yes?] By the time we were told, we are finding out that it's been used before. In other words, that was beyond the...

QUESTION: Well, why did you tell us at the press conference

PELOSI: Well, I told you what our briefing was. And our briefing was...

QUESTION: That you had been told, just not at that particular briefing.

PELOSI: No.

QUESTION: You've been very adamant that you didn't know that waterboarding was used.

PELOSI: No, that is right. [so No means Yes] We were told -- in the briefing that I received, we were told that they had legal opinions that this as legal. We were not told that it was -- that there were other legal opinions to the contrary in the administration. And we were told specifically that waterboarding was not being used. When my assistant told me that the committee had been briefed -- now, I'm not on that committee any more. I'm now out of it. We have a new -- that ranking member wrote the appropriate letter to protest that. And then we find out just slightly more subsequent to that that, perhaps, they were using waterboarding long before they tell us.

QUESTION: (Inaudible).

PELOSI: No. But the point is is that I wasn't briefed. I was told [see, being briefed is not being told]-- informed that someone else had been briefed about it. I'm only speaking from my -- I'm only speaking from my own experience. And we were told that it was not being used. Subsequently, the other members of the committee were informed.

QUESTION: So were you.

PELOSI: No, I wasn't informed. [I was informed but not briefed, why don't you get it] I was informed that a briefing had taken place. Now, you have to look at what they briefed those members. I was not briefed that. I was only informed that they were briefed, but I did not get the briefing.

QUESTION: (Inaudible).

PELOSI: Well, we'll find out.

QUESTION: (Inaudible). They mislead us all the time. I was fighting the war in Iraq at that point, too, you know, saying to my members the intelligence does not support the imminent threat that they are conceding. But what's the point? Yes, they did. They misrepresented every step of the way. And they don't want that focus on them. So they try to turn the attention on us. We had to win the election to make the change. We did. President Bush vetoed the bill. We have a new president who is going to do that.

But the committees can look into and see the timing of who knew what and when and what the nature of the briefing was. I have not been briefed as to what they were briefed on in February. I was just briefed that they were informed that some of the enhanced situations were used.

--------------------------------------------
Related posts:
►Dems Lack Waterboarding Exit Strategy
►Pelosi Surrounds Herself With Herself
►Relax, The Dems Will Screw Up
►Democrats Set To Devour Obama

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Obama's No Lose Photo Decision

Give praise where praise is due. Barack Obama acted wisely in deciding to continue appealing the court-ordered release of detainee abuse photos.

These photos, by the way, have nothing to do with the controversial interrogation program which was the subject of the four legal memoranda recently released, or even the treatment of enemy combatants held at Gitmo. Rather, the photos at issue concern alleged abuse of prisoners by American soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan. Given that we are fighting in both places still, release of photos holds a special danger.

Like the abuse at Abu Ghraib, abuse of detainees at issue in the photos was not for the purpose of interrogation under guidelines approved by the Department of Justice. Prisoner abuse unfortunately takes place in almost every country in the world, sometimes by guards but frequently by other prisoners.

Much of the fury on the Left, however, confuses prisoner abuse with the DOJ-approved interrogation program, and thereby reaches the wrong conclusion on releasing the photos:
It would be nice, though, if someone took the time to point out once again that the very fears about Arab reaction to these photos, and the consequences for our soldiers in the field -- not to mention the radicalizing effect it has, effectively creating future terrorists -- are exactly the main reason why torture doesn't, can't, and never will keep us safe. And why Cheney and Co. utterly failed to actually keep Americans safe, not just during their tenure, but for the foreseeable future.
The interrogation program and policies can be explored (and exposed if need be) without the release of inflammatory photos unrelated to the program. The only purpose to be served by releasing the photos is to embarrass and endanger U.S. soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan with no corresponding benefit.

Additionally, we already know what happened on a fairly wide scale at Abu Ghraib; releasing more photos will not deter future conduct since similar future conduct already is deterred, contrary to the justifications being offered:
The real disincentive caused from the release of the photos is that it will hopefully caution U.S. officials from ever engaging in torture again. As the ACLU’s Amrit Singh explained, the photographs are “critical for helping the public understand the scope and scale of prisoner abuse as well as for holding senior officials accountable for authorizing or permitting such abuse.”
Obama's decision, while professional and correct, also was a no lose proposition politically. If as some are arguing, the legal basis to withhold the photos is weak and any further appeal has a low likelihood of success, then Obama will be vindicated regardless of outcome. If the outcome is an unexpected legal or legislative victory, then Obama will have protected our troops from unnecessary danger; if the ultimate legal outcome is the release of the photos, then it will have been over Obama's objection and he will share no blame for the consequences.

Obama also need not fear the left-wing blogs or interest-groups on this issue. Those who have inextricably cast their lot with Obama are so invested in his success, that they dare not do anything more than gripe and moan in cyberspace. Not one of them has the political fortitude to oppose Obama in Congress or at the polls.

Sometimes doing the right thing for the country also is the right thing politically. Obama seems to have understood that point in this case.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Dems Lack Waterboarding Exit Strategy

Many Democrats in Congress have pushed for release of documents and the holding of hearings on waterboarding and other interrogation methods. Putting aside for now whether the release of such information should take place, it appears that Obama started the ball rolling down hill by releasing the interrogation memos. Barring active intervention by Obama, there will be some further level of document release, Congressional investigations, and public hearings.

This presents a problem mostly for Democrats. Republicans who were briefed on the interrogation methods at least will be consistent, for the most part, in maintaining that the methods were lawful and useful. No Republican is going to be harmed politically by the revelations because most Americans support these methods against people like Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. If leaks of a Justice Department report are to be believed, there will be no prosecutions. Republicans are safe politically and legally.

For Democrats, however, the damage could be significant. Nancy Pelosi already has lost a great deal of credibility from her changing stories. Dozens of other Democrats, including such senior Senators as Jay Rockefeller, apparently also were briefed on the interrogation methods and either were silent, approved, or encouraged the policy.

The irony is that a full blow investigation and hearings will turn mostly on what the Democrats knew, and when they knew it. The Republicans mostly couldn't care less if they were "blamed" for keeping the country safe even if it necessitated waterboarding the mastermind of 9/11 to prevent further attacks. When faced with sacrificing a city versus using harsh interrogation methods, most voters would opt for harsh interrogation.

That the Democrats have more to lose is demonstrated by the looming fight between Democrats in Congress and the CIA. The Democrats are complaining that the CIA is out to get them through selective leaks of documents. These are the same Democrats who cheered when the CIA leaked information damaging to Bush administration policies. So that complaining is going to go no where.

Where this seems to be heading is: (1) Republicans claim Democrats are damaging national security, thereby setting Democrats up for blame when there is a terrorist attack; (2) Republicans claim the mantle of putting the safety of the country ahead of politics; (3) Democrats claim the mantle of putting politics ahead of the safety of the country; (4) Democrats end up exposing Democratic Party leaders to be untruthful, misleading, deceptive and/or too smart by half; (5) the CIA fights as it always has for its institutional interests, in a battle politicians mostly lose; and (6) Democrats turn on each other.

Just a month ago, who would have expected this headline:



This is the same Stenny Hoyer who lost out to Pelosi back in 2001 for Minority Whip, and who Pelosi opposed for his present position of Majority Leader (Pelosi backed John Murtha). No connection, I know. He just wants the truth to come out about Pelosi for the sake of the truth coming out.

Democrats vs. national security. Democrats vs. CIA. Democrats vs. Democrats. This is an investigation only Democrats could dream up, and Republicans can get behind. Republicans will be dragged kicking and screaming into the hearing room so they can ask Nancy Pelosi what she knew and when she knew it. If Democrats shield themselves, Republicans may need to schedule counter-hearings, also known as, "The Whole Truth Commission."

You know it's bad when Media Matters complains that Republicans have managed to change the subject:

Adopting the GOP's emphasis on what Nancy Pelosi and other Democrats knew about the Bush administration's use of harsh interrogation techniques, some in the media have ignored evidence that the Bush administration began using the tactics before briefing Democrats, and that upon learning of them, Rep. Jane Harman unsuccessfully expressed concerns to the CIA.
So Jane Harman is the Democrats' big hope? The same Jane Harman who Nancy Pelosi refused to allow to become Chair of the House Intelligence Committee, despite Harman's seniority? The same Jane Harman who Democrats tried to throw under the bus on the now-dropped AIPAC prosecutions by leaking that Harman was wiretapped talking to a possible "Israeli agent"? That Jane Harman? The only person who did object to waterboarding is expected to run interference for Democrats who went along to get along and who have treated her so poorly in the past several years?

What will Democrats do if they find that other Democrats were morally if not legally culpable in waterboarding? Do the Democrats have an exit strategy?

Here's my prediction of what will happen if Democrats push the investigation to the bitter end causing damage to national security, a political death match with the CIA, and Democrat-on-Democrat finger pointing:

Stenny Hoyer, Speaker; Jane Harman, Majority Leader; Nancy Pelosi, Chair of the House sub-committee on fresh water fisheries; Republicans, unexpected gains in 2010 mid-term elections.
The Democrats wished hard for an investigation into waterboarding and other interrogation methods. They may have wished too hard, because they are about to get what they wished for, with no way out.

UPDATE: This just in, Pelosi Accuses CIA Of Lying. If only I could predict the stock market this well.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Labor Targets Elderly War Hero

His name is George McGovern. He was a war hero, who earned the Distinguished Flying Cross in World War II. He also ran for President once upon a time. And has been a liberal icon for decades due to his opposition to the Vietnam War.

He's 87 years old, and he's still speaking out against injustice. This time it's the deceptively-named Employee Free Choice Act, which is big labor's holy grail. McGovern's opposition to EFCA has earned him the anger of organized labor:

The liberal icon’s public break with the left has produced from his old allies anger, confusion and a failed campaign to persuade him to change his mind on the legislation, which would give workers the option of joining a union by signing cards rather than by voting in a secret ballot.

Instead, McGovern has stuck to his guns in an unlikely campaign that began in the pages of The Wall Street Journal , where he wrote that, for Democrats, abandoning the secret ballot would be “a betrayal of what we have always championed.”

Flirting with sacrilege, he compared his opposition to the bill to “my early and lonely opposition to the Vietnam War.”

I wonder if there are any McGovern Democrats around. And I don't mean people who voted or campaigned for him. I mean Democrats willing to take on their own party and union establishment out of conscience.

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
High Taxes And Union Pensions Are Killing Rhode Island. Duh!
If Obama Builds It, Who Will Maintain It?

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Trump Trumps Thought Police

On the controversy surrounding Miss California's statement at the Miss USA pageant that she believes marriage should be between a man and a woman, Donald Trump embarrassed those in Hollywood and the left-wing blogosphere who tried to portray her answer as hate speech or bigoted. In a single sentence, Trump exposed the utter hypocrisy of the thought police:

“It's the same answer that the president of the United States gave."


--------------------------------------------
Related Post: Liberal Doughboys Afraid of Tea Parties

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook