******************** THIS BLOG HAS MOVED TO WWW.LEGALINSURRECTION.COM ********************

This blog is moving to www.legalinsurrection.com. If you have not been automatically redirected please click on the link.

NEW COMMENTS will NOT be put through and will NOT be transferred to the new website.

Monday, June 8, 2009

Terrorists Booby-Trap Horses, Israel Transfers Vaccine

If you want to know why Barack Obama was spitting into the wind with his "historic" speech to the Muslim world, at least as regards the Israeli-Palestinian issue, there is no better example than this juxtaposition of Palestinians booby-trapping horses as part of a failed kidnap attempt on Israeli soldiers at the Gaza border, while Israel contemporaneously transferred animal vaccines to Gaza:
Under the cover of morning fog, a group of around 10 Palestinian gunmen armed with "huge amounts of explosives" launched a failed Gaza border assault at the Karni Crossing on Monday, in which booby-trapped horses were used, a security source told the Jerusalem Post.

At least four terrorists were killed in an ensuing exchange of fire with the IDF. No Israeli soldiers were wounded in the incident.

The terror cell belonged to the Janud Ansar Allah (Soldiers Loyal to Allah) organization, a small group which is linked to Iran and Hizbullah, the security source added....

Defense Minister Ehud Barak on Monday afternoon praised the IDF's "effectiveness" in foiling the attack, and said it was quite possible that one of the aims of the assault was to kidnap an IDF soldier, a claim made by Hamas television....

Ismail Haniyeh, who heads Gaza's Hamas government, praised the attackers as "martyrs," and said the violence confirmed Israel's "aggressive intentions" toward the Palestinians.

Following the attack, Israel closed the Karni crossing, the main commercial terminal between Israel and Gaza, as well as the Nahal Oz fuel depot.

However, 30,000 vaccine units against foot-and-mouth disease were transferred to Gaza via the Erez crossing, despite the thwarted attack. The IDF said that 125,000 units had been supplied to the Strip in the last three months in three separate transfers, due to the importance of preventing the outbreak of the disease.

In addition, 140 truckloads of humanitarian aid was scheduled to be transferred via the Kerem Shalom crossing.

UPDATE: More on this "incident" at Gateway Pundit, which of course already has a post with photos by the time I was onto this story!

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Hamas Kidnap Attempt Foiled
Hizbullah Loses Lebanon Elections

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Tiger For President

In a speech last February at Wake Forest University, columnist David Gergen "compared Obama’s ability to focus during difficult times to Tiger Woods’ ability to focus during a difficult golf match."

Now this from the opening sentences of a lead NY Times article today:
President Obama was getting his daily economic briefing one recent morning when a fly distracted him. The president swatted and missed, just as the pest buzzed near the shoes of Lawrence H. Summers, the chief White House economic adviser.
What does it mean? Nothing at all. Except that The Times further quotes David Axelrod as follows:
The president “invites debate but he doesn’t tolerate factionalism. And ultimately everybody on the economic team knows that at the end of the day we’re going to hold hands and jump together,” Mr. Axelrod added.
Where is Tiger when we need him? Tiger Woods for President, anyone?

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Hamas Kidnap Attempt Foiled

Hamas reacted to Obama's "historic" speech to the Muslim world by attempting to kidnap Israeli soldiers along the Gaza border last night, in a coordinated assault timed also to coincide with the Lebanese elections:

DEBKAfile's military sources report at least four Palestinians killed after Israeli air force helicopters went into action against Palestinian gunmen who mounted coordinated assaults at several points on the border early Monday, June 8....

Our sources say they were stirred into action Monday by one non-event and two events:

1. They planned to show the flag for a victorious Hizballah and mark Hamas-Hizballah solidarity by kidnapping a number of Israeli soldiers (after holding Gilead Shalit for more than three years). As it turned out Hizballah was defeated, contrary to all expectations, and Hamas failed to abduct any Israeli soldiers, none of whom were lost or injured.
2. US Middle East envoy George Mitchell arrives in Israel and the Palestinian Authority Monday, June 9. Hamas broadcast a reminder to Washington, Jerusalem and Ramallah that no decisions on the Palestinian issue could be carried through without its assent.
3. This was Hamas' reply to US president Barack Obama's Cairo appeal for negotiation and recognition. Orders from Tehran and Damascus, the Palestinian terrorists responded with a fresh round of armed violence.

More at the Jerusalem Post, which lists five terrorists killed:

Ismail Haniyeh, who heads Gaza's Hamas government, praised the attackers as "martyrs," and said the violence confirmed Israel's "aggressive intentions" toward the Palestinians.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Sunday, June 7, 2009

Hizbullah Loses Lebanon Elections

Election result are in from Lebanon, and the pro-Western "March 14" parties are the big winner:
The March 14 alliance clinched around 70 out of 128 seats, maintaining its majority in parliament after defeating the Hizbullah-led alliance in Sunday's crucial elections.

Celebrations broke out in several cities as television stations began airing preliminary results.The opposition confirmed defeat.

"We have lost the election," said a senior politician close to the March 8 alliance. "We accept the result as the will of the people."

More from Middle East News (via Monsters and Critics):


Beirut - Lebanon's Western-backed majority parties celebrated Sunday after winning a crucial parliamentary election that pitted them against the Hezbollah-led opposition.

A close aide of majority alliance head Saad Hariri told the German Press Agency dpa: 'So far we will have at least 70 seats in the 128- member parliament, and the majority is back to rule.'

Shortly after initial results were out, cars carrying the flags of the majority alliance cruised the streets of the capital, Beirut, their occupants chanting 'God bless Hariri and the ruling majority.'

In the main Christian area of Ashrafiyeh, followers of the ruling majority gathered at the main square of the area and started dancing in the streets.

Photo of celebrations in Christian section of Beirut (AFP via Al-Jazeera):



UPDATE: Expect more trouble in Lebanon, as Hizbullah is not taking the results well:

Hizbullah MP Mohammed Raad warned the March 14 coalition on Monday that the group's weapons were not a subject open to discussion.

"The majority must commit not to question our role as a resistance party, the legitimacy of our weapons arsenal and the fact that Israel is an enemy state," Raad told Agence France Presse.

He warned that the outcome of Sunday's vote signaled further political turbulence.

"The results indicate that the crisis will continue, unless the majority changes its attitude," said Raad, an MP who kept his seat in the new parliament. (AFP)

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Jewish History In One Sentence
It's Approaching 3 a.m. for Israel
Law Professor Continues His Personal Intifada

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Bernie Madoff In Gaza

From The Guardian, showing that investment fraud is universal:

Jawad Tawfiq, a 52-year-old Gazan actor and director, was dubious at first, but his nephew insisted. If they could scrape together enough money, the nephew said, large profits could be made from investing in the tunnels that snake beneath the Egyptian border.

"They were liars," Tawfiq said bitterly last week. "They took my money to put in their own pockets. And we are being offered a fraction of what we gave them."

At first the tunnels emerged as smuggling routes; then they became the vital lifeline for a Gaza under economic siege by Israel. But many people who invested in the tunnels now see them quite differently - as a source of ruination.

The tunnel schemes were advertised as opportunities for doubling and trebling money by unscrupulous figures linked to powerful businessmen in Gaza and, allegedly, to senior officials in Hamas, but have instead led to huge losses for ordinary residents of the Strip.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Outer Objects To Outing

Conservative blogger Ed Whelan "outed" an anonymous liberal blogger who penned under the name Publius. Turns out Publius is a junior law professor who was afraid that revealing his identity would jeopardize his career prospects and family relationships. While Publius worried about the reaction of conservatives in academia, career concerns are much more likely and damaging when conservatives blog, since law academia overwhelmingly is liberal.

One of Publius' defenders, and harsh critic of Whelan, is "TBogg" at FireDogLake, whose real name long ago was posted. TBogg specializes in mocking people who disagree with him (like Condoleeza Rice whom he referred to as "Brown Sugar") by distorting his opponents' views, and encouraging others to do the same.

So it is particularly ironic to see TBogg worrying about someone being subjected to ridicule because their real name was exposed:
Bitter out-of-power wingnut welfare recipient Ed Whelan fucks up explaining a joke, gets called out on it, and then goes Full Metal Asshole .... That is to say that publius was "irresponsible" in that he criticized Whelan and, for that crime, Whelan wants to fuck with publius' life. Why else out him?
Worse yet, TBogg has been a proponent of exposing the private lives of people, at least people who disagree with him politically. In 2004, TBogg urged people in New York City to take photos of delegates to the Republican National Convention in the hope of catching people in embarrassing positions [note, the "Ann Coulter" link was in original TBogg post, I encourage you to click on it to see the level of TBogg's blogging]:
Since I wasn't in Boston to cover the Democratic convention (as well as be there when Jonah Goldberg woke up the next morning with his pants on backwards) I feel like I haven't done my part to help restore democracy in America. With the Republicans about to invade NYC (they're the puffy-looking white people with the bad haircuts...yeah, those guys) I was thinking that, with your help, we can help publicize all the good things that the delegates will be doing when they come to the Big Apple. More specifically, I guess, we're really looking for who they're doing.

If you're a New Yorker with a digital camera or a phone camera and better than average run-away speed, we'd love to see any pictures you might have of Republican delegates as they visit the big city...or massage parlors...or hotel lobbies with women who may not be their wives (Handy Tip: If she's attractive and isn't wearing a red white and blue elephant pin, she's probably not Mrs. Delegate from Possum Holler). Details (who and where) would be appreciated. If you've got pictures...we want 'em. If you want credit...you got it. Extra credit for shots in front of strip clubs. Extra extra credit if you catch a pundit. Extra extra extra credit if you catch Rick Santorum going into a pet store. Extra extra extra extra credit if you catch him coming out with Ann Coulter.

All we ask is that you be careful. We don't have a lot of readers and we want to keep the ones we have. And you should ask yourself:

Is this wrong? Is it unethical? Am I playing God with someone's life?

Then take a look around at what has happened in this country in the last four years.

Our operators are standing by...

TBogg's call for embarrassing photos of Republicans was picked up by AmericaBlog, which gained its claim to fame by outing gay Republicans.

There have been legitimate critics and supporters of Whelan. The criticisms ring less hollow coming from people who have not devoted their lives to cheapening online conduct and outing others.

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Are Bloggers Allowed To Speak To People?
A Pox On Annonyblogging-Gate's House

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

What About The Right Not To Wear Head Covering

In his "historic" speech to the Muslim world, Barack Obama spoke up for the rights of women. The first example Obama used was the right of Muslim women in the West to wear hair covering (italics mine):
The sixth issue that I want to address is women's rights.

I know there is debate about this issue. I reject the view of some in the West that a woman who chooses to cover her hair is somehow less equal, but I do believe that a woman who is denied an education is denied equality. And it is no coincidence that countries where women are well-educated are far more likely to be prosperous.
Another odd choice by Obama, just like his claim that "rules" in the U.S. make if "harder" for Muslims to donate to charity. Obama may have thought he was being brave by speaking up for Muslim women in the West, but he was being cowardly because in many Muslim countries women are forced to wear veils, burqas, and other types of clothing which are part-and-parcel of the subjugation of women. By focusing on the right to wear hair covering, not the oppressive practices in which hair covering and more restrictive clothing is forced upon women, Obama threw women's liberation under the bus.

Obama really would have been brave if he told the Muslim world that just as we will fight for the right of Muslim women in the West to wear hair covering, we will stand up for the right of all women not to wear hair covering or other restrictive clothing. That would have been a truly historic statement, rather than politically correct nonsense:
And what's all this about head scarves? "I reject the view of some in the West that a woman who chooses to cover her hair is somehow less equal," Obama said. Talk about a straw man. Isn't the real wardrobe issue for many Muslim women that they must cover, smother and nearly blind themselves in burqas, whether that's their choice or not?
And Obama could break with the tradition, not unique to Obama or to any one political party, of by refusing to have American women representing this country forced to wear head covering when visiting Muslim countries. Hillary Clinton, Laura Bush, Nancy Pelosi, and many other women who are successful and supportive of women's rights have engaged in this practice when traveling to Muslim countries.

Respect is a two-way street, and if we are to respect the practices of Muslim women, Muslims should respect the practices of non-Muslim women.

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Obama's Muslim Charity Canard
"Some Say" Obama Is A Shorter

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Friday, June 5, 2009

Obama's Muslim Charity Canard

A portion in Barack Obama's "historic" speech to the Muslim world was particularly odd. In apologizing for religious intolerance in the United States, Obama said as follows:

Freedom of religion is central to the ability of peoples to live together. We must always examine the ways in which we protect it. For instance, in the United States, rules on charitable giving have made it harder for Muslims to fulfill their religious obligation. That is why I am committed to working with American Muslims to ensure that they can fulfill zakat.
This website has an explanation of zakat. Essentially, it is similar to tithing, in which a percentage of one's worth is contributed to charity each year in fulfillment of a religious conviction.

What rules in the United States discriminate against Muslims? This question, also asked by Ace of Spades HQ, has an answer, and it is steeped in political correctness and worries about racial and religious profiling.

There are Department of Justice guidelines, enacted last year, as to designating which charities support terrorism:

Some Arab- and Muslim-Americans say new Justice Department guidelines that boost the FBI's power to investigate suspected terrorists could target innocent people.

The revised guidelines going into effect Monday will allow agents to use undercover sources to gather information, interview people without identifying themselves and spy on suspects without evidence of wrongdoing.

Critics say the rules will allow for abuses, including more racial and religious rofiling....

Federal officials say current rules came about in the 1970s and limit their ability to investigate people in national security cases.

FBI agents have met twice with community leaders to assure them they won't be targeted, according to the Detroit Free Press.

Based on some other internet sources, it appears likely that these DOJ guidelines are the "rules" to which Obama was referring. I am unable to find any other reference to complaints about "rules" which "have made it harder" for Muslims to donate to charity.

But these DOJ rules do not make it "harder" to contribute, unless the contribution is to a terrorist supporting charity. The fact that many of the prohibited charities are based in Muslim countries does not prove discrimination, rather, it is a reflection of reality.

Why pick this example for his "historic" speech? It seems so petty and pedestrian, in the grand scheme of all the world's problems, to worry about obscure DOJ guidelines meant to halt funding of terrorist organizations.

The selection of this item to highlight in the "historic" speech is a window on what was wrong with the overall tone of the speech. While the speech was good in some specific respects, the overall tone was one of moral equivalence and subjugation to grievance politics. And the Muslim charity canard is a prime example.

--------------------------------------------
Related Post: "Some Say" Obama Is A Shorter

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

"Some Say" Obama Is A Shorter

I didn't know what the term "shorter" meant until I started blogging. A "shorter" is someone who exaggerates someone else's opinion, or creates a false choice between two extremes. Back in the day, such form of argument would be called setting up a "strawman."

As others have pointed out, Obama loves strawman arguments. His favorite form of argument is to set up false choices, and false equivalencies to make his point. Frequently, Obama uses the device of what "some say" or similar words to accomplish his phony set-up.

One excellent set of examples were the arguments Obama used in support of the February 2009 stimulus package:

Barack Obama promotes his gigantic spending bill in the Washington Post, with a string of straw man attacks against critics: Barack Obama - The Action Americans Need.

"In recent days, there have been misguided criticisms of this plan that echo the failed theories that helped lead us into this crisis — the notion that tax cuts alone will solve all our problems..."

I have not heard of a single person who says “tax cuts alone” are the solution.

"... that we can meet our enormous tests with half-steps and piecemeal
measures..."

Who has ever said this? Who would say such a ridiculous thing?

... that we can ignore fundamental challenges such as energy independence and the high cost of health care and still expect our
economy and our country to thrive.

“Ignore energy independence and health care?” Again, where can I find the pundits who write these things? Because I read a lot of political opinion pieces, and I don’t recall ever seeing such a viewpoint advocated.

This is the same kind of empty, false rhetoric he employed in his campaign—attacking stances that no one has espoused, and no one even would espouse. The very definition of a straw man argument.

Obama's "historic" speech to the Muslim world yesterday was full of shorting.
Moreover, the sweeping change brought by modernity and globalization led many Muslims to view the West as hostile to the traditions of Islam.
So "many Muslims" object to modernity, and we are supposed to give credibility to those who want to live in the 15th Century just because "many" are afraid of the modern world.
The attacks of September 11th, 2001 and the continued efforts of these extremists to engage in violence against civilians has led some in my country to view Islam as inevitably hostile not only to America and Western countries, but also to human rights.
The "some in my country" constitute the majority of the population who have legitimate fears of Islamic extremism and terrorism. By setting up the equation this way, Obama is creating a false equivalency between those who fear attack and those who attack.
I know there has been controversy about the promotion of democracy in recent years, and much of this controversy is connected to the war in Iraq. So let me be clear: no system of government can or should be imposed upon one nation by any other.
Promoting democracy is not the equivalent of imposing a system of government. The false analogy of promoting democracy to imperialism leaves those who seek freedom in places such as Iran left to fend for themselves. Stating that "we will support" certain universal freedoms, as Obama does in his speech, means nothing without actual support. So much for hope.
Freedom of religion is central to the ability of peoples to live together. We must always examine the ways in which we protect it. For instance, in the United States, rules on charitable giving have made it harder for Muslims to fulfill their religious obligation. That is why I am committed to working with American Muslims to ensure that they can fulfill zakat.
Zakat is an Islamic term for the giving of charity. What rules prevent Muslims from giving to charity, unless what Obama means is that we prosecute people who give to Muslim charities which support terrorism. Why use this example of a lack of religious freedom in the United States? Is a rule which might limit charitable contributions really the equivalent of rules in places such as Saudi Arabia which prohibit the practice of other religions?
So long as our relationship is defined by our differences, we will empower those who sow hatred rather than peace, and who promote conflict rather than the cooperation that can help all of our people achieve justice and prosperity.
The choice is not between promoting conflict or promoting justice. Obama uses this false choice to minimize the horrible treatment of women and religious minorities throughout much of the Muslim world. Which gets me to the worst of the worst arguments in the speech, the argument that there is an equivalency between women in the West and the Middle East:

Likewise, it is important for Western countries to avoid impeding Muslim citizens from practicing religion as they see fit - for instance, by dictating what clothes a Muslim woman should wear. We cannot disguise hostility towards any religion behind the pretence of liberalism....

I know there is debate about this issue. I reject the view of some in the West that a woman who chooses to cover her hair is somehow less equal, but I do believe that a woman who is denied an education is denied equality. And it is no coincidence that countries where women are well-educated are far more likely to be prosperous.

The equation of the rights of women in the West with the wearing of head covering is bizarre. The forced wearing of burkas and face covering, the stoning of women who are immodest, and the lack of women's voting rights and educational opportunities, do not take place in the West. That someone, somewhere may object to a Muslim woman covering her face for a drivers license photo, as took place recently, hardly is the equivalent of what takes place in several conservative Muslim societies. Huffington Post blogger Peter Daou has it right:

Is that a joke?

With women being stoned, raped, abused, battered, mutilated, and slaughtered on a daily basis across the globe, violence that is so often perpetrated in the name of religion, the most our president can speak about is protecting their right to wear the hijab? I would have been much more heartened if the preponderance of the speech had been about how in the 21st century, we CANNOT tolerate the pervasive abuse of our mothers and sisters and daughters.

You see, "some say" that Obama has a huge ego which necessitates that he create strawman arguments as part of his self-aggrandizing personality. "Some argue" that Obama uses false moral equivalencies and dichotomies because he has no real, substantive arguments.

"There are those," some of whom are part of the "many people," who think Obama is a shorter.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Obama Speech In One Sentence

Here is a one sentence summary of Barack Obama's "historic" speech to the Muslim world:

"I have no right to tell you how to live, because we're as bad as you are, but here's how you need to live."


--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Unaccountable Commission May Run Healthcare

Three card monte is a scam in which the sucker is led to believe he is following the winning card, when in fact the skillful dealer has distracted the sucker into following the wrong card. The sucker never wins.

Right now, everyone's focus is on Obama's "historic" speech to the Muslim world in Cairo. But the real action came in a letter Obama sent to the Senate proposing to empower the 17-member Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) with the same level of power over the health care system as the Base Realignment and Closure Commission had over the closing of military bases:
To identify and achieve additional savings, I am also open to your ideas about giving special consideration to the recommendations of the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), a commission created by a Republican Congress. Under this approach, MedPAC's recommendations on cost reductions would be adopted unless opposed by a joint resolution of the Congress. This is similar to a process that has been used effectively by a commission charged with closing military bases, and could be a valuable tool to help achieve health care reform in a fiscally responsible way.
The 2009 MedPAC member list is here. While MedPAC currently only makes suggestions regarding Medicare payments and costs, the Obama proposal would greatly expand MedPAC's power over a large percentage of the economy -- and the health and welfare of tens of millions of people -- because MedPAC's actions would have the force of law without any significant accountability. The likelihood of a joint resolution of Congress against anything MedPAC did is so small as to make MedPAC a law unto its own.

Since Medicare rules and funding drive so much of the health care industry, MedPAC will become a de facto health care Czar. And it would not be surprising if MedPAC's jurisdiction was expanded beyond Medicare itself.

While some are cheering that the move "actually looks able to deliver on controlling costs," such controls will come at the cost of citizens having any control over their health care. Somehow blind faith in an unaccountable commission has become the method of rescue for those who otherwise demand freedom. If you didn't like when a military base was was closed in your state, wait until you are denied a surgery or treatment because it is deemed too expensive by MedPAC.

The analogy of closing military bases to making health care costs decisions if fallacious. The base closing commission was a reaction to large excess capacity in military bases, largely as a result of pork barrel earmarks. Taking politicians out of the closing process was the only way to close military bases, so that politicians would not take the blame. There is no excess capacity, however, in health care services. To the contrary, if anything, there is a lack of capacity, or at least a capacity which costs too much because of new technologies and treatments.

An unaccountable commission restricting access to health care services simply is nothing like an unaccountable commission closing unneeded military bases. And if the history of the Base Closing commission is any indication, there will be plenty of irrationalities from this supposedly rational process, mostly in the form of illusory cost savings.

There will be winners and losers, and the losers will lose not their jobs, but potentially their lives. No wonder Obama wants to rush this through Congress this summer in time for an October signing. If people really knew and had time to focus on what Obama was proposing, the MedPAC and similar proposals would fail.

Obama's speech to the Muslim world will change nothing. Obama's MedPAC and similar proposals will change everything. And you were watching the speech.

--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

Obama Doesn't Bow to King Abdullah

Depends on what the meaning of "bow" is. Because leaning down to have a medal put over your head is not a bow. How could anyone think otherwise? From LGF:

Please note! Barack Obama is absolutely not bowing to King Abdullah! He’s receiving a medal.

That is not a bow. It’s very, very different from a bow.

Thank you for listening.

No, thank you for listening.



--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Sotomayor's Supporters May Spin Her Out Of A Job

The White House explanation for Sonia Sotomayor's 2001 "wise Latina" statement was that Sotomayor used a "poor" choice of words and certainly would "restate" the language. This spin made no sense, as the full text of the 2001 speech made clear that Sotomayor did not misspeak or use uncertain language. Rather, the speech taken as a whole and in context was a reiteration of standard identity-politics in which Sotomayor specifically was responding to and rejecting identity-neutral approaches of Justice Sandra Day O'Connor and Judge Miriam Cedarbaum.

Sotomayor seemed to confirm this defense yesterday, although obliquely, through a statement released by Judiciary Committee Chair Patrick Leahy:
"Of course one's life experience shapes who you are," but she added, "Ultimately and completely, a judge has to follow the law no matter what their upbringing has been."
Now it is revealed, by Greg Sargent, a supporter of Sotomayor no less, that Sotomayor used almost identical language in a 1994 speech:
“Justice O’Connor has often been cited as saying that “a wise old man and a wise old woman reach the same conclusion in dueling cases. I am not so sure Justice O’Connor is the author of that line since Professor Resnik attributes the line to Supreme Court Justice Coyle. I am not so sure that I agree with the statement. First, if Prof. Martha Minnow is correct, there can never be a universal definition of ‘wise.’ Second, I would hope that a wise woman with the richness of her experience would, more often than not, reach a better conclusion.”
So the White House spin holds no water. There was no misspoken word. The language in question appears to be part of Sotomayor's stump speech.

The spin by Sargent and others is that since Republicans did not object to the language when Sotomayor was nominated to the Court of Appeals in 1998, there must be nothing wrong with the language. Sargent's spin makes less sense than the White House spin.

First, as noted in the The Economist, the 1998 speech did not contain the explicit comparison to the judgment of white males, as does the 2001 speech, so it is less objectionable on its face. Second, regardless of whether anyone noticed the language in 1998, Sotomayor now is being nominated to the Supreme Court and people have noticed. It's like arguing against a speeding ticket because last time the cop let you go. Third, as Ben Smith points out, the existence of the 1994 speech "also makes it harder for the White House to cast it as a slip of the tongue."

The White House thought it was doing Sotomayor a favor by spinning the "wise Latina" language as a poor choice of words. Pat Leahy thought he was doing Sotomayor a favor by spinning the language as nothing of significance. Greg Sargent thought he was doing Sotomayor a favor by spinning the language as old news.

Although I reject identity-politics in the judicial context, I am not yet convinced that Sotomayor would be a bad choice, given the alternatives. I'm still taking a wait and see approach. There may come a point at which I would support Sotomayor, but that point may be moot at this rate, as the spin from Sotomayor's supporters is doing more damage to Sotomayor than the "wise Latina" language itself.

As with Nancy Pelosi's shifting explanations of her knowledge of waterboarding, Sotomayor's supporters' spin is surrounding Sotomayor with herself, which is a losing strategy. Keep putting forth more ridiculous spin, and Sotomayor's supporters may just end up spinning her out of a job.

UPDATE: JustOneMinute points out that the 1994 speech used the term "wise woman" not "wise Latina."
--------------------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Because Only The Far Right Incites Violence








See HotAir and Michelle Malkin for more examples of "kill Bush" memorabilia.

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Remember Ilan Halimi
Phony Outrage Over "Armed And Dangerous"
Further Proof Liberal Bloggers Need To Study History

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

Monday, June 1, 2009

What Sandra Day O'Connor Said

In my post yesterday, I noted that Washington Post columnist Ruth Marcus wasn't "buying" the Obama administration spin that Sonia Sotomayor made a "poor" choice of words or misspoke in her speech in 2001 when Sotomayor said “I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn’t lived that life.”

Among Marcus' reasons for believing that Sotomoyor "meant what she said and said what she meant" was that Sotomayor "was deliberately and directly disputing remarks by then-Justice Sandra Day O’Connor that a wise old woman and a wise old man would eventually reach the same conclusion in a case."

To follow up on Marcus' point, here is the language used by Justice O'Connor to which Sotomayor was responding. The differences in approach between O'Connor and Sotomayor are quite startling. O'Connor explicitly rejected the "new feminist" approach which appears to be advocated by Sotomayor.

The language is from a 1991 N.Y.U. Law Review article by O'Connor which appears at 66 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 1546 (sorry, can't find an internet link for it, but you can access it from Westlaw or Lexis)(italics mine):
Just when the Court and Congress have adopted a less sanguine view of gender-based classifications, however, the new presence of women in the law has prompted many feminist commentators to ask whether women have made a difference to the profession, whether women have different styles, aptitudes, or liabilities. Ironically, the move to ask again the question whether women are different merely by virtue of being women recalls the old myths we have struggled to put behind us. Undaunted by the historical resonances, however, more and more writers have suggested that women practice law differently than men. One author has even concluded that my opinions differ in a peculiarly feminine way from those of my colleagues.

The gender differences currently cited are surprisingly similar to stereotypes from years past. Women attorneys are more likely to seek to mediate disputes than litigate them. Women attorneys are more likely to focus on resolving a client's problem than on vindicating a position. Women attorneys are more likely to sacrifice career advancement for family obligations. Women attorneys are more concerned with public service or fostering community than with individual achievement. Women judges are more likely to emphasize context and deemphasize general principles. Women judges are more compassionate. And so forth.

This “New Feminism” is interesting, but troubling, precisely because it so nearly echoes the Victorian myth of the “True Woman” that kept women out of law for so long. It is a little chilling to compare these suggestions to Clarence Darrow's assertion that women are too kind and warm-hearted to be shining lights at the bar....

I would hope that your generation of attorneys will find new ways to balance family and professional responsibilities between men and women, recognizing gender differences in a way that promotes equality and frees both women and men from traditional role limitations. You must reopen the velvet curtain between work and home that was drawn closed in the Victorian era. Not only women, but men too, have missed out through the division of work and home. As more women enjoy the challenges of a legal career, more men have blessings to garner from taking extra time to nurture and teach their children.

If we are to continue to find ways to repair the existing difference between professional women and men with regard to family responsibilities, however, we must not allow the “New Feminism” complete sway. For example, asking whether women attorneys speak with a “different voice” than men do is a question that is both dangerous and unanswerable. It again sets up the polarity between the feminine virtues of homemaking and the masculine virtues of breadwinning. It threatens, indeed, to establish new categories of “women's work” to which women are confined and from which men are excluded.

Instead, my sense is that as women continue to take on a full role in the professions, learning from those professional experiences, as from their experiences as homemakers, the virtues derived from both kinds of learning will meld. The “different voices” will teach each other. I myself have been thankful for the opportunity to experience a rich and fulfilling career as well as a close and supportive family life. I know the lessons I have learned in each have aided me in the other. As a result, I can revel both in the growth of my granddaughter and in the legal subtleties of the free exercise clause.

Do women judges decide cases differently by virtue of being women? I would echo the answer of my colleague, Justice Jeanne Coyne of the Supreme Court of Oklahoma, who responded that “a wise old man and a wise old woman reach the same conclusion.”

This should be our aspiration: that, whatever our gender or background, we all may become wise-wise through our different struggles and different victories, wise through work and play, profession and family." [footnotes omitted]

--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Sotomayor "Meant What She Said and Said What She Meant"
Prominent Constitutional Scholar Warns Of "Stealth Nominee"
Sotomayor's Damned Statistics
Those Other "Unfortunate" Words

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook