******************** THIS BLOG HAS MOVED TO WWW.LEGALINSURRECTION.COM ********************

This blog is moving to www.legalinsurrection.com. If you have not been automatically redirected please click on the link.

NEW COMMENTS will NOT be put through and will NOT be transferred to the new website.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

And Now We Stereotype Blacks As Liberals

Gallup has come out with another of its surveys showing how different groups self-identify in terms of liberal-conservative-moderate.

The headline of the Gallup release focused on the liberal leanings of Asian-Americans, but the survey also showed that "non-Hispanic blacks" self-identified slightly more conservative (29%) than liberal (24%) with a clear plurality in the center (43%):

This self-identification does not fit the usual narrative of blacks being liberal, at least according to Matthew Yglesias who writes as follows (emphasis mine):
I think that what this pretty clearly shows is that ideological self-identification surveys are not very useful. By any objective measure African-Americans are the most left-wing racial group in America. But African-Americans don’t seem to like the term “liberal.” And even though very few black people have conservative political opinions, 29 percent of them describe themselves as “conservative.” I think this proves beyond a doubt that widely touted results about ideological self-identification are producing garbage numbers. Actual people clearly don’t understand these terms the same way political reporters understand them. It’s just false that more African-Americans are conservative than liberal—that these surveys produce that result doesn’t tell us a surprising new fact about black political views, it tells us that the surveys are badly designed.

Actually, I think this self-identification may be very meaningful. It may reflect that the voting pattern of blacks in favor of the Democratic Party is not the result of liberalism, but other historical and political factors. And at no time were those factors more prevalent than in 2008.

What the liberal elites, epitomized by the folks who run Think Progress (where Yglesias blogs), fear most is a realization in the black community that black self-identification does not match black voting in favor of Democrats. So rather than examine the issue with any level of nuance, the views blacks have of their own political leanings are thrown out as garbage.

In fact, blacks are not that far off in self-identification from the total of all Americans in Gallup's survey released last month:

Isn't it interesting how the liberal elites are unwilling to allow blacks to self-identify without treating the result as "garbage" when it doesn't match liberal dogma?

There is an opportunity for conservative politicians to make inroads into the black vote, and it would be a mistake to ignore that opportunity.

Update: Tom Maguire has more on the tendency of liberals to disregard this political self-identification: "Blacks vote for lefties, but I don't know if that makes them lefties."

I am reminded of the California Prop. 8 campaign, when black ministers came out against the "liberal" position in favor of gay marriage, and the black vote in favor of Prop. 8 (and therefore against gay marriage) was a decisive factor.

Related Posts:
The Great Deception of 2008
How Do They Think This Stuff Up? Part 2
How Do They Think This Stuff Up?

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook
Bookmark and Share


  1. Proposition 8 (pro-marriage amendment) won in California in November 2008 because of the unusually high turnout by blacks and Hispanics who showed up to vote for Obama. The support for gay marriage is lower in those two groups than among whites which put gay activists groups in a quandary. They couldn't issue their death threats to those two groups because they would look like racists so they issued them against conservative white Christians who turned out in smaller numbers than usual. Obama crushed McCain in CA.

    Being a gay liberal is like being a conservative who voted for Scott Brown only to see him endorse McCain, wait forever to demand to be seated (he wasn't prepared because he didn't expect to win) and then give his first interview to Barbara Walters instead of a Fox News reporter. Two-year clueless establishment Republican senator.

  2. im gonna question he asian one all orientals people i know are confuscianist conservatives, this must include middle eastern asians who despite conservative values worry about republicans and muslim relations

  3. Self-identification in politics is meaningful only to the extent it allows those other than youself to gauge the extent to which your behavior conforms to your rhetoric. The Big O self-describes as a moderate. Does that make him one? Not in my corner of the universe.

  4. "...this proves beyond a doubt that widely touted results about ideological self-identification are producing garbage numbers. Actual people [African-Americans/black people] clearly don’t understand these terms the same way political reporters understand them...."

    From my reading of this, Think Progress (Yglesias) just made a racist slur against black/African-American people: in a nutshell, they are too stupid to understand the term "conservative" and thus any numbers their opinions produce are "garbage."

    What an elitist hack! Will anyone call out Yglesias? I won't hold my breath.

  5. marie...you just did. good job my friend!

    Black folk..in my experience are more libertarian...extremly conservative and religious in some matters, but liberal in others like some social issues...