******************** THIS BLOG HAS MOVED TO WWW.LEGALINSURRECTION.COM ********************

This blog is moving to www.legalinsurrection.com. If you have not been automatically redirected please click on the link.

NEW COMMENTS will NOT be put through and will NOT be transferred to the new website.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Deception and Tyranny Key To Health Care Reform

David Brooks has a piece in today's NY Times in which he explains how Barack Obama will pass health care reform. The solution can be summed up in two words: Deception and Tyranny.

After allowing the political process (and all those messy bad interest groups) to put forth their ideas, a large health care reform package will be proposed in a rush to the finish line:
This brings you to the final stage, the scrum. This is the set of all-night meetings at the end of the Congressional summer session when all the different pieces actually get put together.

You want the scrum to be quick so that the bill is passed before some of the interests groups realize that they’ve been decapitated. You want the scrum to be frantic so you can tell your allies that their reservations might destroy the whole effort (this is how you are going to get the liberals to water down the public plan and the moderates to loosen their fiscal rectitude).

Notice not a hint of concern on Brooks' part about deception being the key to passage of sweeping health care reform. We've been there, and done that, as in the February 2009 stimulus package. How quaint is the concept of people actually knowing what they are getting in legislation.

After the deception, will come the tyranny, in the form of MedPac, the unaccountable commission which will make life and death decisions for the nation as to which surgical or medical procedures, services and medications are cost effective for the nation. As in Britain and elsewhere, these decisions will have life and death consequences for patients, who will have no redress against this supposedly benign health care dictator:

But you won’t be able to honestly address the toughest issues and still hold your coalition. You won’t get the kind of structural change that will bring down costs long-term. In the scrum, Congress will embrace the easy stuff and bury the hard stuff.

Which is why you have MedPAC. That’s the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission that you want to turn into a health care Federal Reserve Board — an aloof technocratic body of experts that will make tough decisions beyond the reach of politics. You can take every thorny issue, throw it to MedPac and consider it solved.

Conservatives will claim you’re giving enormous power to an unelected bunch of wonks. They’ll say that health care is too complicated to be run by experts from Washington. But you’ll say that you are rising above politics. You’ll have your (partial) health care victory.

Brooks attitude about "experts" making health care decisions smacks of elitism; an unelected, unimpeachable panel will deprive you of the right to treatment not because the treatment will not help you, but because the treatment is too expensive for the system of government health insurance. If empowering individuals and doctors to make these decisions is politicizing health care, then call me political.

While I disagree with Brooks' attitude, I fear he is correct in the ultimate point. The only way the Obama administration and Democrats can force through the types of changes they envision for the health care system is through deception and tyranny. Honesty and freedom have no place in a system of national health care.

Related Posts:
Unaccountable Commission May Run Healthcare
Health Insurance Fraud Exposed

Follow me on Twitter and Facebook


  1. I kind of agree. Deception and tyranny are the only tools the Democrats have. There's a saying, "When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail." This is just the way Democrats operate, because they know their entire agenda would be unpopular if everyone knew about it.

  2. Strong words, but absolutely true.

  3. Quoting Brooks:
    "But you’ll say that you are rising above politics."

    Not to sound hysterical, but that is almost verbatim the approach described by Goldberg in "Liberal Fascism" -- the quest for a "third way" behind which we can all unite (and avoid messy democratic politics.)

  4. .
    The arrogance is staggering. I know several Obamamaniacs who do not like this Health Care deal at all. We must tell all our Liberal friends, risk a little argument to put some facts and Canadian and British HC stories in their heads.


    absurd thought -
    God of the Universe says
    DESTROY your health care system

    ration care to save money
    just wait for critical care

    absurd thought -
    God of the Universe loves
    a health care bureaucracy

    keep patients running around
    charge them every time

  5. I truly believe the purpose of universal healthcare is to kill off the Boomer generation. Of course the tyrants making these decisions aggressively and on purpose disallowing our input will get their private healthcare the rest of us won't have access to even if we can afford it.

    The end result for this country in 30 - 50 years would be a smaller, beaten and useless America lacking any vestiges of what made this country great, paying 90% in taxes while being supported at subsistence level by a cruel and all-powerful government. At the top, a cadre of rich, smug, Marxist conspirators, not noticeably different from the ruling class in the old USSR. Oh, wait...we have that last part now.

    I guess we'll find out if the fighting spirit in the American people still exists and can subvert the goals of the tyrants. Who would even want to live to see the worst come to pass? Actually, maybe they don't want to kill us off - they want us to commit mass suicide.

  6. I believe the problem is surmised quite well over at

    under the

    "Obama's "Two-minute Hate" now focused on AMA" entry.

  7. It's so refreshing to find someone who realizes what's really going on--"Medicare for all" being slammed down our throats bit by bit through, as you so aptly put it, deception and tyranny. Once the Obamacrats have destroyed private insurance, they'll go after doctors' pay and patient rights--and start excluding expensive procedures and medicines. Sock away money now into a special savings account so you can fly to India when you want that specialized procedure to save your life. The Obamacrats will never pay for it (unless it's for one of them--I can't wait to see what behind-the-scenes system they set up for themselves).