Nicholas Kristoff has found the answer to traditional Palestinian suicide bombers, hijackers, and hostage takers: A non-violent movement led by Palestinian women.
But for now, Kristoff finds it's still a dream, because it depends on what the meaning of "non-violence" is.
Describing one protest, seeking the removal of a security barrier on the West Bank the Israelis erected to keep out suicide bombers, Kristoff observed:
But then a group of Palestinian youths began to throw rocks at Israeli troops. That’s the biggest challenge: many Palestinians define “nonviolence” to include stone-throwing.Apparently stone-throwing was not limited to protests involving Israeli solders.
Soon after, the Israeli forces fired volleys of tear gas at us, and then charged. The protesters fled, some throwing rocks backward as they ran. It’s a far cry from the heroism of Gandhi’s followers, who refused even to raise their arms to ward off blows as they were clubbed.
Kristoff says "we were stoned by Palestinian children in East Jerusalem" but gives no details. I wonder if Max Blumenthal got it on tape, as the vicious Kristoff family attacked Palestinian children who had no choice but to resist with stones.
This is an improvement, though. Before the security barrier was constructed, Kristoff and his family would not have been able to eat in a restaurant, or ride a bus, or attend a Bar Mitzvah ceremony in Israel without fear of an imminent explosion.
I've cited the statistics before. From 452 Israelis killed in 2002, terror attacks within Israel are down almost to nothing as a result of the security barrier and Israeli military actions in the West Bank and along the Gaza border.
If a true non-violent Palestinian movement arises, it will be only because the alternative no longer is available.
--------------------------------------------
Related Posts:
Mr. Netanyahu, Tear Down That Wall For Our Suicide Bombers
Double Standard on Americans Hurt In Israel
Greenwald Agonistes
Follow me on Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube
They're actually not calling for the wall to be removed. They're calling for it to be rerouted so that a large chunk of their village and its most fertile farm land isn't stolen by Israel.
ReplyDeleteNotice that he didn't make the family vacation celebrating Kurdish nationalism. That would be dangerous.
ReplyDeletePalestinian kids chucking stones is a venerable game that is centuries old. A children's book from the Children of Many Lands series from the late 19th or early 20th century describes it. When my daughters went to the Rambam grade school in Lod in the 1980s, they had to walk through an Arab neighborhood and the Israeli Arab kids threw stones at them as a matter of course.
ReplyDeleteAt least in the old goat and sheep-herding days, chucking stones at jackals had a purpose...